Mumbai: Taking note of the 300-plus fires and rise in toxicity, noise pollution and AQI in the city this Diwali despite civic and police personnel’s best efforts, Bombay High Court on Thursday suggested there would be no alternative but to order a larger ban on firecrackers and allow only “community firecrackers’’ on permissible grounds if people remain insensitive and lack civic sense.“This would be the only solution to release the city from toxicity. We are struggling with the pollution… There is also vehicular and industrial pollution. We need to make the city more livable. Health of others is our main consideration… Need to be proactive,’’ said Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale.“We will have to pass some drastic orders in the larger interest of lakhs of citizens in the city… It appears people have decided they will not change their minds… There will be tremendous noise pollution till 3 am. Police are helpless, they did their best. We will have to nip it in the bud, and the only way will be to ban all firecrackers in Mumbai and only community firecrackers will be permissible at designated community grounds for a limited period, like in some foreign countries,’’ said Justices Kulkarni and Gokhale at a hearing of a suo motu PIL on noise pollution during festivals.A senior counsel Sanjeev Gorwadkar for petitioner Dr Mahesh Bedekar also suggested imposing a “complete ban” on the sale of firecrackers across Maharashtra, drawing an analogy with the prohibition on Gutka—flavoured tobacco which the Supreme Court too had upheld as Constitutionally sustainable within the bounds of the permissible “reasonable” restrictions. Justice Kulkarni said he saw the parallels given the serious risks indiscriminate use of firecrackers poses to human health, birds, pets, environment and even property.State lawyer Jyoti Chavan said they cannot have a ban for the entire state.An amicus curiae (friend of court) advocate Anand Pai appointed by the HC, cited SC and orders from other nations including Germany to suggest a ban on fire crackers even on private roads and permitting them only in community grounds. State lawyer Jyoti Chavan said a total ban may not be an answer but cited nearly 500 police cases registered this Diwali where she said action was taken, warnings issued and firecrackers worth over 20 lakh, seized. For BMC, its counsel Joel Carlos sought time to come back with solutions from the civic body.Counsel Rohaan Cama for Awaaz Foundation said environmental protection and right to health had been given supremacy by the SC over commercial interests or any economical hardships.The HC bench considering the seriousness of the issue held a marathon hearing all afternoon and beyond the court’s rising hour of 5 pm. The Judges asked how many fires occurred in Diwali and was told 350. That’s “alarming” said the bench, “We cannot have celebrations which is damaging to humans and properties like this…people’s mindset has basically not changed. Awareness message were reflected but people have no consciousness or sensitivity for social cause or compassion towards others, or how hazardous it is even for them… Toxicity was the highest during Diwali…What happens to old citizens? Nothing has improved… fundamental rights of others are violated…firecrakcers are used not just in festivals but during matches, marriages, election victories’’ the Judges observed orally, but they added, “Mumbai’s fabric is its togetherness. That’s the great quality of this city.’’The HC said while it appreciated a civic ban on firecracker sale, it is “High time we ban noise and polluting firecrackers completely.’’ Before it passes any orders, the HC set out to hear submissions of lawyers and clarified there was “nothing adversarial in this matter. It is purely in the interest of society if we don’t take timely steps what will be the effect on the city is left only to imagination.’’“Are we not supposed to look at this when expert bodies are warning us about the particulate matters firecrackers release and its harmful effects which last beyond the two days of festivities,’’ the bench asked at one point saying, “we cannot succumb to any commercial interest’’ and added, “everyone cannot afford to have air purifiers at home’’.The HC cited a headline of Mumbai Mirror, saying “civic sense up in smoke”.When asked MPCB counsel Jaya Bagwe said the AQI was high during Diwali and HC cited another newspaper to say it was 400. When authorities said it was from mobile sensors, bench said, “Don’t be in a denial mode at all. Accept it then we can decide how to tackle it.’’“Lack of civic sense must be countered with a total ban of firecrackers,’’ said Pai and Gorwadkar said “when drastic situation has arisen it calls for drastic measures as part of a precautionary principle’’ pointing out to lack of proper implementation of rules and orders. The matter is now reserved for orders.
