Cal HC upholds death penalty of man convicted in child rape-murder case | Kolkata News


Cal HC upholds death penalty of man convicted in child rape-murder case

Kolkata: Calcutta High Court on Tuesday upheld the death penalty for a 45-year-old Hooghly man convicted of rape and murder of a 5-year-10-month-old girl, observing that the convict showed ‘no sign of remorse or repentance’ and “any kindness shown to him will be misplaced mercy”.An exception to Calcutta High Court’s consistent position on reformative justice, the division bench of justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray observed: “While ensuring that an accused gets ‘just’ treatment, the courts must also not be oblivious to victim justice and the agony suffered by the victim’s family members.”Justice Banerjee, in a 72-page judgment, also observed that he is “conscious” that there are decisions of Supreme Court on how the shift is taking place from retributive justice to reformative justice. “However, in the present case, I am of the view that reformation of the appellant would be a far cry. Any attempt at that would be an exercise in futility. This I say because the extreme depravity and meanness of mind that the appellant has demonstrated by committing the crime in the barbaric manner. These are his ingrained instincts and characteristics. In my opinion, it is highly improbable that a person like the appellant can be reformed,” Justice Banerjee opined.Noting that the victim’s family had not even received Rs 10 lakh compensation, HC enhanced it to Rs 15 lakh and directed the state to pay it within two months, while observing, “It is very much unfortunate that the state is clamouring for capital punishment of the convict but has failed to comply with the direction of paying the victim compensation to the parents of the deceased.”The convict was sentenced and convicted by a Chinsurah court on Jan 14 and 15, 2025.The incident took place on Nov 24, 2024. Ashok Singh lured the victim to his place with the promise of chocolate. The victim did not return and her body was found stacked near a ‘balaposh’, naked with blood in her vagina and anus. After the sexual abuse, her head was smashed against a surface. Singh was not a stranger to the victim. He was a neighbour, whom she called ‘Jethu’.The bench opined that there was “no missing link in the case” as Singh’s semen was found in the private parts of the victim. The reason for death was “intracranial haemorrhage associated with signs of recent forceful penetration of vagina and anus.”“In spite of knowing that such a type of brutal sex with a child might take her life, he did not resist himself although he was a mature and sensible person…The ordeal which the child experienced or passed through at the relevant point of time cannot be explained in any language,” the division bench elaborated.While it was argued that the convict is an illiterate, poor person, who had no scope to receive value education and did not attain the knowledge of the benefit of values in life, the division bench observed: “I did nothing wrong with the victim,” the convict said during examination. “From this attitude of the convict coupled with other evidence on record, it is clear that he has no repentance or remorse and he is a very hard nut to crack. The attitude of the convict shows that criminal instinct is embedded in his mind set,” the judge said.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *