Sheena Bora murder case: Prosecution rests case after 9 years of trial | Mumbai News


Sheena Bora murder case: Prosecution rests case after 9 years of trial
150 witnesses were examined

Mumbai: After nine years, four judges, a divorce, claims that the victim was seen alive, bail for the three accused and an almost year-long delay caused by the pandemic, the prosecution has closed its evidence in the Supreme Court-expedited Sheena Bora murder trial after examining 150 witnesses. The prosecution communicated this to the special CBI court on Tuesday.On trial are former media executive Indrani Mukerjea and her former husbands Peter Mukerjea and Sanjeev Khanna.Unless the accused choose to examine defence witnesses, the special CBI court will record their statements under Section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code, with questions framed based on the evidence placed during the trial. This will be followed by final arguments by both sides. The court will then reserve the judgment.CBI has alleged that Indrani, Peter, Khanna and driver Shyamvar Rai conspired to abduct and murder her daughter, Sheena Bora, from an earlier relationship. It said on April 24, 2012, Indrani, Khanna and Rai abducted Sheena in a car, sedated and strangled her, and later disposed of her body in a forest in Pen, Raigad.The alleged murder came to light in Aug 2015 during Rai’s interrogation by Khar police following his arrest in an illegal arms case. Indrani and Khanna were arrested. In Nov 2015, when police filed a chargesheet against Indrani, Khanna and Rai, Peter was also arrested and charged with murder and conspiracy. The case was handed over to CBI. Rai later turned approver and deposed as a prosecution witness.In Jan 2017, the court framed charges against the accused for murder, destruction of evidence, criminal conspiracy, kidnapping and giving false information about an offence. Indrani and Khanna were also charged with attempting to murder Mekhail; no such charge was framed against Peter. All pleaded not guilty.The key witnesses included Rai; Sheena’s father, Siddhartha Das; Indrani’s son, Mekhail Bora; her daughter with Khanna, Vidhie Mukerjea; Peter’s son from an earlier marriage, Rahul Mukerjea, who was engaged to Sheena; Indrani’s former assistant, Kajal Sharma; former housekeeper Pradeep Waghmare; and IPS officer Deven Bharti. The last witness was CBI investigating officer K K Singh.In Dec 2023, the CBI submitted a list of 23 witnesses it would not examine. Among the “unreliable witnesses” was former Mumbai police commissioner Rakesh Maria. During city police’s investigation, Maria was appointed director general, Home Guards.Among the motives alleged by CBI was Peter and Indrani’s opposition to Sheena’s relationship with Rahul. Despite their disapproval, Rahul and Sheena had got engaged and were planning to marry in 2012, the agency claimed.The trial began in Feb 2017 with the deposition of police officer Ganesh Dalvi. The defence objected on legal grounds when he began deposing about Rai’s alleged confession, arguing that criminal procedure and evidence law did not permit use of statements made to a police officer as a confession. The objection briefly halted proceedings.Rai, the prosecution’s star witness, took the stand in July 2017. His testimony, which largely matched his confession statement before a magistrate, detailed the alleged planning and execution of the murder in Indrani’s car and the disposal of Sheena’s body. The trial then proceeded steadily, with 67 witnesses examined by 2020.In Oct 2019, while in custody, Indrani and Peter ended their marriage by mutual consent. They had married in 2002. In March 2020, Peter was granted bail by Bombay HC, days before the Covid lockdown stalled the trial. Proceedings resumed in Feb 2021 with the cross-examination of the 67th witness, a handwriting expert, who had last deposed in March 2020.The trial faced another delay in late 2024 when the presiding judge was transferred. In March 2025, special CBI judge J P Darekar said the trial would resume on a day-to-day basis from March 10, following HC’s directions. Darekar is the fourth judge to preside over the case after H S Mahajan, J C Jagdale and S P Naik-Nimbalkar.A twist came in Dec 2021, when Indrani wrote to CBI claiming that a Byculla jail inmate had told her Sheena was alive and living in Kashmir. CBI dismissed the claim as a “figment of imagination”. Indrani later said she wanted to keep the plea on hold.In May 2022, SC granted Indrani bail. She later wrote a book, appeared in an OTT documentary on the case and acted in plays. In June 2022, Bombay HC granted Khanna bail.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *